ATV Connection Magazine

Mac or PC?

(Click here to view the original thread with full colors/images)




Pages: 1


Posted by: nccracing

I prefer Mac . Grew up with a pc then tried a Mac and been hooked ever since . Dont know what Powerismygame is talking about ?

Posted by: BlackandRedWarrior

Personally I'm a Linux guy. Use XP Pro at work though. I've never been really enamored with Windows. Though it did take me years before I finally went Linux 100% and don't plan on going back. If/when you make the switch, make it for the right reasons. The applications are out there. Mac OS X has a UNIX derivitive at it's core (FreeBSD). It is inherently more secure than Windows. You do gain some security through obscurity. Most (pretty much all) virus, worms and other malware are written for Windows because it's the most popular.

With the open source base under that sexy skin, there's a lot of applications out there that can be had for free (as in beer because they are free as in speech and use open licensing.)

Just about any type of app that I want I can get for Linux. Some may not be as featurefull as their Windows (or even Mac) counterparts, but they are up and coming.

Friesen...WTF. You can't run Mac OS X on an x86 machine. Unless you get Darwin (the FreeBSD base of OS X). And even with Apple's shift to Intel, you won't be able to load OS X (or it's successor) on a regular Intel based machine. Apple will still use their proprietary firmware to lock OS X to their hardware. But you'll be able to run MS WindowsXP|Vista|Whatever on their hardware.

Posted by: BlackandRedWarrior

Quote

Originally posted by: TehWarriorGuy
ive never actually used a linux so i know nothing about them are they good in anyway? and whats the main reason you switched to linux? hr>


Actually Linux itself is just the kernel. The very lowest level of the OS. Up until just recently you could actually put the kernel on a floppy ready to go.

On top of that is the GNU system of utilities, and other basic programs. GNU stands for GNU is Not UNIX. It's a recursive achronym. You'll find a LOT of resurcive achronym names in the Open Source/Free Software community.

There are probably over 300 distributions of Linux out there. Anything from a standard distribution (Red Hat, Debian, SuSE/Novell, Ubuntu, Gentoo, Mandrake, etc.) to very specialized distributions (Knoppix (and it's derivatives) is a live distro on a CD/DVD, IPCop is a firewall distribution (there are serveral firewall distrobutions out there), and some rescue CD distributions for fixing installs (AND Windows).)

Personally I use Fedora Core (it's a version that's community supported that eventually develops into Red Hat's Enterprise Linux distributions) and some old Red Hat releases. I can take a Fedora Core release and install "Everything" (4 nearly full CDs, or about 2.5GB on a DVD), or strip it down to a very basic install (about 400MB or so).

As far as user interfaces go, the best way to describe how things are set up is much like Windows 3.1x on top of DOS. You don't need to run the GUI (X Window System). Most people installing servers bypassing installing X as you don't really need X to manage a server. I manage mine from the command line. And in fact, none of my servers actually have monitors attached, let alone a keyboard and mouse.

There are two main desktop environments in use: GNOME GNU Network Object Model Environment (or something like that) and KDE (K Desktop Environment). Each of these have their own widget sets and programming (GNOME uses GTK/GTK+ (GIMP Took Kit) and KDE uses QT). Most of GNOME was originally written in C, whereas KDE uses C++. Personally I like KDE. I just have never liked GNOME. Previously it used Enlightenment as the window manager (how the windows look, which can load themes, like XP and WinAMP can) and it was a steaming pile of dog..., IMHO. The nice thing is, just because you use one, doesn't mean you can't use an app designed for the other as long as the support libraries are present. Little trivia: the rendering engine on the back side of Apple's Safari web browser was built by the KDE Team for use in the Konquerer web browser. Most Linux users usually opt for Mozilla Firefox for a GUI browser.

That's kind of a primer, but it goes much further.

The first time I switched full-time, I hose my Windows 95B install and wanted to try something else. I had tried Caldera[1] OpenLinux 1.2 Lite in about '97 when I was in Jr. College. Wouldn't work well with my graphics card at that time. So I went back to Windows. Then the hosing happened in April of '99. Ended up picking up RedHat 5.1. Jumped in for a while, then switched back to Windows for some stuff. I've gone full-time Linux on a few occasions. This time I'm thinking it will be permanent. I like the flexibility that Linux provides. And for tinkering it's easy on the pocketbook. Give me broadband and a CD/DVD burner.

UNIX-style systems do things differently than Windows apps. You have a tool and it does things well. You have another one, and it does it's thing well. You put them together and create a tool chain. Pretty much most CD/DVD burning is handled by one or two command-line programs (cdrecord and growisofs). There are different graphical front-ends (Xcdroast was the first and is still very popular, with K3B (a KDE App) and GCombust now popular as well.)

Video editing is one area where this is evident. There's about 3 main packages that people use: MainActor which is a commercial package/trial app. Does a decent job. Next is Kino. It works great for basic editing. The higher end app is called Cinelera, which is actually developed by ONE guy. Most people are scared off by the hardware spec: 2x AMD Opteron 4GB RAM and like a TB of storage. Note: that spec can actually handle real time editing of HD streams! I used Kino to make a DVD and it took about 8 hrs (could have been 7 hrs, but I was still using the system for 2 hrs) to encode from DV (Sony D8 camcorder source) to DVD Spec MPEG-2 video of 1 hr. Nice thing about Cinelera: Render farm! And you don't have to pay for each node. I haven't done it yet, but I plan on it. It will actually use the render farm to do real-time background rendering (like for previews.)

Kino especially uses small tools on the backend: dvgrab to pull the DV over Firewire/iLink/IEEE 1394, mplayer package to encode the video, outputs XML for a program called DVD Author that actually builds the menus and filesystem layout. Then you use growisofs or mkisofs and cdrecord to burn the CD.

If you really want to take a look at Linux on the desktop, download Knoppix. It's a live CD (runs off the CD w/o needing to be installed). It won't touch your existing install.

Probably one of the biggest issues is lack of vendor support for hardware. It's very evident in the printing dept. But when I'm looking to buy hardware, I make sure it's supported first. (I have a SanDisk CF card reader at home: Linux doesn't support the revision I have (or didn't.)) I also have a USB 2.0 card that has issues sometimes. However my Adaptec Firewire card works great. Printing is one of the worst ones to deal with. I specifically bought an HP LaserJet 1200 because it supported PostScript (nearly all Linux apps will output PostScript natively) and I really only printed text and it's MUCH cheaper for laser to do text than an inkjet.

Any questions? It's easier to answer questions than to just start yacking about it. You can always try to find a Linux Users Group in your area and go to a meeting. They are open to the public. I belong to a local one here.

One thing to watch for is the use of Free. There's a saying in the community: Free as in speech, not as in beer. It's about Freedom. Do what you want, not what your vendor wants.

[1] Caldera is now known as The SCO Group. They lost in the Linux marketplace. Per seat licensing was one reason people were bailing on Microsoft. They have now changed from a software house to a litigation company. And they wonder why they keep losing business. People don't want to do business with a company that's going to sue them. SCOG (they are NOT SCO (The Santa Cruz Organization, now known as Tarantella), they bought SCO's UNIX business) has sued: IBM, DaimlerChrysler (the only thing left of that suit after DC whipped them like a red headed step-child) is whether they took too long to file a license report with SCO because they had stopped using the licensed software years ago.) and AutoZone. The IBM case is win or die. If they lose that case, expect to find SCOG stock in the men's restroom at Armonk, NY. RedHat answered the IBM suit with a "put up or shut up" case against SCOG. So far SCOG hasn't put up or shut in any case. They keep changing why they are suing IBM. See http://www.groklaw.net

Posted by: MnFriesen

once I get my external hardrive, I will be using windows xp and mac OS.....I am just going to use a multi boot on it and have both for whatever occasion the situation calls for

Posted by: MnFriesen

Quote

Originally posted by: tyler711
Quote

Originally posted by: blindside350
I own a PC, grew up with them. But the great things about Macs are you don't have to open the case to upgrade.


img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-happy.gif" border="0">

PC all the way. I'm a nerd, so at least I base my decision on years of experience


are you actually a nerd? or just on the computer alot?? I am anerd myself, I know c++ qbasic Visual basic java, html stuff like that...and will soon be learning pearl...I am also smi decent with hardware...I can rip apart and rebuild a computer in about 10 minutes at max...that is taking everything out and putting it back in...

Posted by: blindside350

I own a PC, grew up with them. But the great things about Macs are you don't have to open the case to upgrade. When its time to upgrade, pick it up and throw it in the trash and buy a new one! And gaming is fantastic too, all 6 of the games, not including the apple logo game, thats pretty sweet. And you don't have to worry about what games are good because all the games on the Mac already game out on the PC like 5 or 6 years ago.

Posted by: blindside350

Quote

Originally posted by: BeerSmurf
Quote

Originally posted by: blindside350
I own a PC, grew up with them. But the great things about Macs are you don't have to open the case to upgrade. When its time to upgrade, pick it up and throw it in the trash and buy a new one! And gaming is fantastic too, all 6 of the games, not including the apple logo game, thats pretty sweet. And you don't have to worry about what games are good because all the games on the Mac already game out on the PC like 5 or 6 years ago.


Wow, you must be one of those experts I've heard so much about.
So, are you saying that the PCI-X, AGP 8x, Serial ATA, PC3200, USB, and Firewire connections in Macs don't work?
Or is it that the processor upgrades from PowerLogix, Newertechonolgies, or Sonnet are not real?
Or were you trying to be cute by applying the limitations of the tiny enclosure of the Mac Mini to all Macs?
Just curious.
Anyway, back to World of Warcraft, on my Mac.


It was a parody of the Mac Switch thing from roosterteeth Linky. I've tried macs, great machines visually (montiers are gorgeous!) But like i said I am used to PCs, and probably never switch don't need to, I can run everything on my PC without even flinching. Props to Apple for switching to Intel, the just have to switch to AMD

Posted by: BeerSmurf

I have several Macs and a PC.
I really depends on what you want it for.
I do everything on my Mac laptop, 12" PowerBook, but I play games on my PC.
There are more PC games but the Macs are more trouble free for almost everything else.
Don't let PC fans compare price of bottom end PCs with full blown workstation Macs.
You can get a Mac mini or a iBook cheap.
New macs also use almost all the same accessories as PCs now. So you can probably use your existing USB devices including multibutton mice.
So, unless you're a hardcore gamer, get the Mac, you won't be sorry.


Posted by: BeerSmurf

Quote

Originally posted by: blindside350
I own a PC, grew up with them. But the great things about Macs are you don't have to open the case to upgrade. When its time to upgrade, pick it up and throw it in the trash and buy a new one! And gaming is fantastic too, all 6 of the games, not including the apple logo game, thats pretty sweet. And you don't have to worry about what games are good because all the games on the Mac already game out on the PC like 5 or 6 years ago.


Wow, you must be one of those experts I've heard so much about.
So, are you saying that the PCI-X, AGP 8x, Serial ATA, PC3200, USB, and Firewire connections in Macs don't work?
Or is it that the processor upgrades from PowerLogix, Newertechonolgies, or Sonnet are not real?
Or were you trying to be cute by applying the limitations of the tiny enclosure of the Mac Mini to all Macs?
Just curious.
Anyway, back to World of Warcraft, on my Mac.



Posted by: BeerSmurf

Quote

Originally posted by: mywifesquad
Quote

Originally posted by: TehWarriorGuy
Well i was just wondering what u guys use a mac or a pc? i personally use a pc but im thinkin of switching to a mac. All of my friends have em and they're pretty sick.img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-wink.gif" border="0">


PC, never tried a mac. You can get a decent pc for $700.00 these days. how much for a mac?


The Mac Mini starts at $499.00.
iBooks start at $999.00 for a laptop.



Posted by: ThrashAndCrashUntilItsTrash

use a PC....wish I had a MAC

Posted by: hondabuster

I got sick and tired of the constant sercurity breaches and updates, and using anti virus software.
Mac is the only way to go...never needs updating, or anti virus software, it just works.


Posted by: tyler711

Quote

Originally posted by: blindside350
I own a PC, grew up with them. But the great things about Macs are you don't have to open the case to upgrade.


img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-happy.gif" border="0">

PC all the way. I'm a nerd, so at least I base my decision on years of experience

Posted by: tyler711

I've tried linux, but just the loss of convenience of having a different OS was too much for me. Installing hardware was annoying, games wouldnt run, and a lot of the programs I require won't run on it (WMP10 for napster, etc.)

I must say that apple has genious business strategy (part of why I hate them). They are like a legal monopoly of their own systems. More power to them. I like windows because that's what I'm comfortable with and know inside and out.

Posted by: tyler711

I am working at becoming a nerd I've mainly been focusing on troubleshooting windows and apps, that kinda thing. That's what people usually need help with (and will pay for help with) but I know some c++, enough html to get by, and am in my second year of Java (for AP exams).

Also decent with hardware, can dis/re assemble a computer and replace whatever. But again I focus on the real "useful" stuff like setting up HT's and stereos and whatever.


I don't mess with languages im not taking classes in becuase I figure I'll just get into bad habits; once I've had some schooling with them I start messing around on my own. I still have quite a few years of school so I figure I'll have time for classes in whatever I want to take.

Posted by: tyler711

Quote

Originally posted by: TehWarriorGuy
ive never actually used a linux so i know nothing about them are they good in anyway? and whats the main reason you switched to linux? hr>


Its free img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-happy.gif" border="0">, as are many of the apps for it. Stable, well supported, it can do a lot.
http://linux.about.com/od/linux101/l/blnewbie0_4.htm

Posted by: tyler711

Only your first born if you have a coupon.

Posted by: tyler711

http://www.walmart.com/catalog/product.gsp?product_id=3946852 Compaq Presario desktop with a 17" monitor. $458.

Not my computer of choice, but it's specs are not bad at all:
17" flat screen CRT monitor
2.93 GHz Intel Celeron D Processor 340
256 MB DDR SDRAM
Integrated CD-RW/DVD-ROM combo drive
80 GB hard drive
9-in-1 memory card reader
Integrated 10/100Base-T networking interface

Posted by: UltimateAussie

i like pc's i have never had security breech or anything, i built my own computer and i made it for 400 bucks thats with a free moniter and it would have cost me about a 1500 to buy a mac that does what my computer does. i also have 4 firewalls and 2 virus scanners. but when it comes to film editing or anything graphic involved macs are the way to go.

Posted by: mywifesquad

Quote

Originally posted by: TehWarriorGuy
Well i was just wondering what u guys use a mac or a pc? i personally use a pc but im thinkin of switching to a mac. All of my friends have em and they're pretty sick.img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-wink.gif" border="0">


PC, never tried a mac. You can get a decent pc for $700.00 these days. how much for a mac?

Posted by: XtremeSkier

Dude i have a vaio just like u!

how could u want something differnet!

it's such a sweet computer

Posted by: XtremeSkier

yeah well i've heard Macs are freakin amazing but my Vaio does everything i need it to, i think i'd rather have my parents spend money on something they want then on me since they do enough of that already

Posted by: TehWarriorGuy

Well i was just wondering what u guys use a mac or a pc? i personally use a pc but im thinkin of switching to a mac. All of my friends have em and they're pretty sick.img src="i/expressions/face-icon-small-wink.gif" border="0">

Posted by: TehWarriorGuy

Quote

Originally posted by: nccracing
I prefer Mac . Grew up with a pc then tried a Mac and been hooked ever since . Dont know what Powerismygame is talking about ?


hahaha ive never owned a mac ever ive grown up with pcs too but for some reason i just like macs more now

Posted by: TehWarriorGuy

Quote

Originally posted by: hondabuster
I got sick and tired of the constant sercurity breaches and updates, and using anti virus software.
Mac is the only way to go...never needs updating, or anti virus software, it just works.


yup

Posted by: TehWarriorGuy

Quote

Originally posted by: UltimateAussie
i like pc's i have never had security breech or anything, i built my own computer and i made it for 400 bucks thats with a free moniter and it would have cost me about a 1500 to buy a mac that does what my computer does. i also have 4 firewalls and 2 virus scanners. but when it comes to film editing or anything graphic involved macs are the way to go.


yup any pic or movie editing macs own in that category

Posted by: TehWarriorGuy

i know! i love my vaio!! but i think i might have to switch to a mac. The only real game i play is CS and im givin up soon so...ill probably get a mac for my next comp

Posted by: TehWarriorGuy

ive never actually used a linux so i know nothing about them are they good in anyway? and whats the main reason you switched to linux?

Posted by: powerismygame

i hate mac. there very anoying in the way they operate.

the programs are somhow lost. you dont deleat it it is just not there anymore.